Not all the new gang members need to die in RDR II. "Knowing what we know, we can't figure out how the GT-R goes around the Nurburgring so fast." Arthur gave them the money to flee and start over, which turned out to be money wasted because their new life prospecting in the Tundra failed. The IRL reason, of course . TL;DR - In RDR1, John doesn't mention Arthur because 1) it hurts him to think of him, 2) he's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, and 3) he said not to look . 2022GamesToday-Your place for discussion, help, guides, reviews, videos, questions, news, and anything else games related. Also, why is Arthur not mentioned in rdr1? This part of my theory is based largely two key things: That there are different timelines presented in the Red Dead story, and that one of these timelines is packed with supernatural elements while the other is mostly mundane. Your email address will not be published. Anyone playing RDR1 after RDR2 is going to be very confused whenever John speaks about his past. Oct 25, 2017 He took inspiration from Toshiro Mifune, John Wayne, and Rob Wiethoff, all of whom played John Marston in the game and its sequel. The protagonist of the 2018 video game Red Dead Redemption 2 is Arthur Morgan, a fictional character. During the mission " Political Realities in Armadillo " John tells the Marshal " You know, I hear you speak and suddenly, I'm reminded of how some of the people I respected the most in my life had a problem with authority ". They were basically brothers. off topic, but correct me if im wrong, was landon ricketts a outlaw before he came a vigilante ? I go back to the living room and *greet* Abigail, who is still sewing on the sofa), JOHN: (irritated) Why would you say that?, ABIGAIL: (awkward) Its true, aint it?, JOHN: (difficult) Look I can talk about him it just hurts is all., I think the retconned reason (the story reason) that John doesnt talk about Arthur in RDR1 is because he misses him like a brother, but also because hes kinda ashamed of the fact that Arthur saved his ass on more than one occasion, and ultimately saved his wife and son. The rest of the crew is probably long dead. You missed out Arthur spluttering; "Well, it looks like I've had my dead red redemption". While Hosea wouldve been a little bit more well-known than him, the gang member with the most fame after Dutch would have been Micah, who became very well-known in 1907 for his reign of terror and mysterious death. The Dutchs demand for blind faith, on the other hand, probably didnt help much. Wild Mint is extremely common to find near streams, marshes and moist meadows all over the map. Nothing is said about it. Why is so necessary to treat your players like lazy morons? Is Arthur referenced in rdr1? RubyLane is an internet site. This hidden portion of the map is highly likely to be playable later, either in Red Dead Online mode or as a result of an expansion. BY: Phillip Tinner . By He might have let slip once that any of the hugely influential RDR2 characters existed at all, but he never does because he never knew them. Who is Arthur Morgan based off of? The ring John uses to propose to Abigail is Arthur's old wedding ring, and after Arthur dies John begins journaling in an effort to help keep his memory alive. Need help with all Achievements optimization, Gambit has no direction and that is why it has failed, Shattered Realm was criminally underrated as a Seasonal Activity and as a concept, Heavy weapons and how to make the best use of them in survival, I Hope That Necrom Does What Elsweyr Did: A Synopsis of Masterful Storytelling. Maybe he changed his identity like Micheal did in GTA V? John also completes the main story of RDR2 with like 20 grand in cash. "I went outside once. Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in Americas unforgiving heartland. So why is arthur morgan never mentioned in rdr1 if him and johr were pretty close. This means that a north wind blows from the north,, Anything goes with stone, black, white, coral, aqua, any shade of blue, baby pink, hot pink, emerald green, olive green, and red. Though, the time for release of Red Dead Redemption 2 has been officially confirmed there is no news regarding the release of the fourth version the game. They addressed it through story and character in many subtle ways to discover, rather than a single throwaway line. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. "Nobody talks about it," Holmes said. As it says the title, let's speculate why Arthur is not even mentioned in Red Dead Redemption 1 by John Marston, as far we know now, Arthur is the enforcer and like "the big brother" that looks after the gang, why in the original RDR (based 12 years later) is like he never existed? By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. yep, well, thats called retroactive continuity. Undead Nightmare appears to take place in the same timeline as RDR2, but we know it can't take place in the same timeline as RDR1. After how grateful he was to Arthur at the end of chapter 6, makes him feel disrespectful. The immediate effect is pretty much the same. Where did all that money go by RDR1? In rdr1, Arthur Morgan was never mentioned. A lot of the memories would also probably be unpleasant, given that he was left for dead. There's very little reason to mention anyone else than the people he's hunting down. [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1? We wouldnt be here if it werent for him. I Wish Infected Was A Permanent Featured Playlist Game A good summary of the whole ending. how to save arthur morgan from tuberculosis. eastriver and, DeltaV20, Youll have to use a few of the games bugs. Everyone knows that. The past is behind us now. That something is redemption for all of his gang members, and Arthur is his most important. The ending we get with John is the one that would have happened if Arthur had been around to save his ass and teach him the importance of family. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. It's because he doesn't exist in RDR1's timeline. The point is, the writers didnt lazily ignore the fact that John didnt mention Arthur in RDR1. View Page. Bill and Javier didnt get the focus and screen-time they deserved in RDR 2. Playing as Arthur Morgan, the player is cast into the very end of the wild west. Jack and Abigail sit in the living room. Because of doing these things, Arthur's parents gave him the options that Pal will either stay in the garage or be sent away until he's housetrained, both of which were to Arthur's objections. slimeball supreme and, AnthMUFC-Champs, To me, I feel like they kept Bill's original backstory to his character.,just not playing up the whole abigail love angles, but I do see where your coming from Also, john and Arthur's relationship to me soured because he got abigail pregnant, Jack was born and then he left for a whole year. MARKUS. They addressed it through story and character in many subtle ways to discover, rather than a single throwaway line. Arthur has no doubts about everything, every plan, every idea, and every person because that is who he is. 2. How hards that to grasp for some. How do I track animals using my binoculars? Companion theory: RDR2 and Undead Nightmare take place in the same timeline, separate from RDR1. Do Red Dead 1 and 2 have the same map? Luckily for Arthur, in 1899 there's no TV where he can can be heard yelling "Where's Ah Munneh???" By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. The closest RDR was to mentioning Arthur was when John speaks to Bonnie saying a "friend" aka Arthur helped him escape the gang life. why is arthur not mentioned in rdr1. All Rights Reserved. There are, to my knowledge, no supernatural occurances in RDR1 apart from possibly the Stranger, and even he might be explained by misfiring bullets and a network of intelligence contacts. Best Work Writer's Discussion 2016 [The "I Love Karen Daniels" fanfic]. 6 Arthurs Hat Becomes Johns While John has access to both his and Arthurs signature hats when control is turned over to him, the end of Chapter 6 clearly demonstrates that Arthurs hat transforms into Johns hat in some way. GTANet.com 2001-2023. I (John) walk in and join them. Arthur gave them the money to flee and start over, which turned out to be money wasted because their new life prospecting in the Tundra failed. bubble tea consumption statistics australia. Comment *document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute("id","a9662a6c7cffb085762f3b1d1f5f3454");document.getElementById("b7ae61571b").setAttribute("id","comment"); Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Why do they never mention Arthur Morgan in RDR1? Currently Playing: SRTT, Forza 4, Kingdoms of Amalur, AOT:TDC, also if you dont want spoilers DONT look up help with any of the Hunts or Collectibles. I think Arthur will be like an older brother to John, never turn his back on him and will go on to live a peaceful life on a ranch somewhere in the end and was never mentioned because john had no resentment towards Arthur warranting redemption unlike the other gang members. Privacy Policy. Would he have helped John and his family? John in the first RDR was kind of evasive about any topic that pertained to the gang. Because his character was probably created after RDR1 was completed. My point is: There's no particular reason for him not being mentioned. They did a very good job of it in RDR, a masterful job, so they should be congratulated for it; theres no point acting like they had a big plan 10 years ago with the first game. Is the money still in the cave rdr2? Throughout the game's six chapters, Arthur develops quite a bit more than John ever did. Witness Protection. Ive spent a lot of time at the ranch with the Marston Family. It's part of what makes this such a good game, that famous attention to detail. Yes, it should have been from a story perspective, but the story of RDR2 was conceived after RDR1, and I don't think Rockstar expected RDR1 to be the success it was. rdr2 pc teleport mod. on an angle tackle the defender tracks; riverside public utilities rebates Most of what Arthur did was considered an action of the gang as a whole, not just him. TL;DR - John doesnt mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) Hes ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back. He tells people that he was in a gang with Dutch, Bill and Javier, they left him for dead in a botched robbery and he left the gang. Whats amazing to me is that, even now, I still catch little moments I havent seen yet. He is well aware of what he did for him. Content posted in this community. The epilogue picks up a few years later and follows John Marston, the protagonist of Red Dead Redemption as he tries to build a home for his girlfriend Abigail and their son Jack. There is even an appearance of the green mask that starts all the craziness from Undead Nightmare in a fence's shop in RDR2, connecting the two parts of what appears to be the same timeline with physical evidence. may not be appropriate for all ages, or may not be appropriate for viewing at work. There is a conversation between Abigail and Jack where Jack brings up that he has memories of the family's time with the Van Der Linde gang but doesn't remember much due to him still being a toddler back then. Well, it's very obvious the real reason is because Arthur wasn't even imagined until the release of the first game. Presumably, John hadnt had anything to do with Arthur for something like 5-10 years by the time of RDR1. From PC, Xbox, PS5 and all your other favorite gaming platforms, theres some amazing titles for everyone to look forward to in the coming year. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. Because there was never a need to mention Arthur. Ultimately the decision does not matter. Why is so necessary to remove all realism from the game? He has pleaded not guilty. He took inspiration from actors such as Toshiro Mifune, John Wayne, and Rob Wiethoff, who played John Marston in the game and its predecessor. It's not that big of a deal if you ask me , Arthur was not even thought of yet when making RDR1 and considering how the rdr2 story went. Everyone knows that. The south side of any house will receive, The direction from which wind blows (such as the north wind) is named after it. TL;DR In RDR1, John doesnt mention Arthur because 1) it hurts him to think of him, 2) hes ashamed that Arthur saved his family, and 3) he said not to look back. GTA Online New Bonuses for 27th April 2023 - The Last Dose Hard Mode Event is here alongside rewards for completing the missions and extra payouts, the Issi Rally is back, and more! Audax2. He didn't get mentioned the same way Saddie wasn't mentioned, or the native american dude, or Micah Bell, Pearson, Lenny, Joshua, Karen, etc GTANet.com 2001-2023. Required fields are marked *. how do you make wheel in little alchemy; what does miss honey describe as her greatest triumph Open menu. Why is Arthur not mentioned in RDR1? P.S: of course we know that they didn't think on this new character when they created RDR1, but let's theorize just based on the storyline's perspective and not the limitations or the guessing that R* had back in 2010 vs now. Then who?" :: Red Dead Redemption 2 General Discussions. The point is, the writers didnt lazily ignore the fact that John didnt mention Arthur in RDR1. Little moments like the one above are worth discussing. Luckily for Arthur, in 1899 there's no TV where he can can be heard yelling "Where's Ah Munneh???" burger_mike and, saintsrow, Rockstar needs to do RDR3 and tell us what in the mother of fuck happend before and during Black Water. ), JOHN: You know, I did a little saving you myself., JOHN: (pointedly) Youre my family, boy., (Jack leaves. Micah then flees in enrage, while Arthur dies of tuberculosis while watching the sun rise from the mountainside. Well-known antique/collectible publications (classified ads section) Hummel collector club, The main advantage of having a south-facing home or garden is the amount of light youll get. TL;DR - John doesn't mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) He's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back. From what we've read from the previews, I think that's all dependent of the player. Wear them with, Copyright 2023 TipsFolder.com | Powered by Astra WordPress Theme. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. +(91)-9821210096 | paula deen meatloaf with brown gravy. You are reading about how to rob bank rdr2. Cookie Notice Cancel. By 1911, he's not mentioned at all, which does make sense in some ways because, as said, he went down in history as one of a group and anything he did was thought to have been done by the gang as a whole. The Strange Man seemed to be a lot about moral, so I could see this hinting at John Marston, that he is a liar. Because they made RDR1 before RDR2? Likely as simple as that. Home. John says, "Imma curb stomp that rat!" The REAL Reason Why Arthur Morgan Is NEVER Mentioned In The First Red Dead Redemption Game!Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards \u0026 More Games: https://www.g2a.com/r/mrbossftwIn todays Red Dead Redemption 2 video - I'll be explaining why I believe Arthur Morgan was never mentioned in the first Red Dead Redemption game!SOURCE:https://gtaforums.com/topic/909282-speculation-topic-why-arthur-is-not-mentioned-in-rdr1/#commentsMy Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/MrBossFTWMy Snapchat:https://www.snapchat.com/add/MrBossSnapsMy Twitter: https://twitter.com/#!/mrbossftwMy Instagram:http://instagram.com/jamesrosshudginsHope you enjoyed this video! In many ways, Red Dead Redemption 2 is more or less a character study of Arthur. The graphics were great but the story sucked." Its worth discussing. /r/RedDeadRedemption - A subreddit dedicated to Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games, the creators behind the Grand Theft Auto series. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). It's like when Han Solo talks at great length about his long history with Lando Calrissian, even though he didn't mention him at all in the first Star Wars film. Abigail is sewing while Jack reads a book. Said it in General but I'll post it again here-, Well John does vaguely allude to other gang members in RDR. Here are the best content by the team thcsnguyenthanhson.edu.vn synthesize and compile, see more in the section How. Why is so necessary to make mediocre/bad game rather than a epic one? Posted on . Im six hours in and Im liking every minute. The point is, the writers didn't lazily ignore the fact that John didn't mention Arthur in RDR1. Undead Nightmare definitely depicts events in a setting which is similar but much more fantastical than the one we see in the main game, and different, mutually exclusive events happen in that timeline, such as John dying and turning into a zombie in the end. Why is Arthur not mentioned in RDR1? This will happen more often than not in any outlaw town you enter.. ' All of these things I mentioned also give you the ability to open new missions and unlock new abilities. While talking to Ross, he says something like: "First it was Bill, then Javier, now Dutch. or what im hoping is that if they are alive marston was on good terms with everybody else. Uncategorized. The IRL reason, of course, is that Arthur was not created until RDR2. So he killed both John and Uncle, knowing that John isn't someone he can trust with this. Its part of what makes this such a good game, that famous attention to detail. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. (Looks at me) Do you, John?, JOHN: (pause) No. Even in 1907, hes barely mentioned at all, so history forgot about him. He he saved us!, ABIGAIL: Well, yes. We do get to see how being part of the Van der Linde Gang has affected this much younger John. Morgan probably appears to sacrifice himself to save Marston and Marston goes along with Arthur faking his death to the gang. Maybe the gang would've survive if he wasn't sick?. 1907 Roleplay REDM Hiring Admins, Serious Roleplay, Active Development. By 1911, hes not mentioned at all, which does make sense in some ways because, as said, he went down in history as one of a group and anything he did was thought to have been done by the gang as a whole. Would he have steered Dutch right? Plus, based on John's dealings in RDR with the remaining old gang members, generally didn't go so well. John is well aware of this as well. Call Us Today! It could also be argued that Red Dead Revolver takes place in a similar but alternate reality from RDR1. DarrenC1888, UltraGizmo64 and. I wish they were developed a lot more, particularly in terms of their relationship with John. Arthur betrayed him by failing to trust him and putting his faith in him. I follow him and *greet* him before he steps outside. - Lucca Torre, Scuderia Ferrari. im thinking either. The one he wears in the first game, in particular. It seems more likely to me given the fact that we see the world of RDR2 populated with aliens, time travelers and ghosts that John never mentions Arthur, Hosea, Sadie or Micah ever in RDR1 because they never existed in RDR1 John's timeline than because he forgot or just didn't like talking about it. they only got who was left in the surrounding area. Once John killed Micah there wasn't much left for John to say about Arthur and at least we know John keeps him well into his thoughts. Sign In . There are clever retconned reasons for it. So I was kinda curious too why Arthur wasn't mentioned. For Arthur? To me that says that other gang members are still alive, but not a priority (or not as well known to the public) for John to track them down. Karen Jones. For most of the past 10 years, Jimmerson has been behind bars, yet never given the opportunity to tell his side of the story at trial. Isgho Votre ducation notre priorit . No looking back., (Jack gets up and walks out. Any theories? Only one I remember from rdr1 was bill and Dutch. NO SPOILERS PLEASE: does RDR2 address why Arthur is never mentioned in RDR1. How often do you talk about former workmates to people you just met? Our old protagonist from RDR1, who lets Arthur Morgan take the wheel in RDR2. In RDR1 the Pinkerton Agency was simply interested to use John to catch former gang brothers who were operating arround the boarder area, namely WIlliamson, Escuela and Dutch. or maybe. Ross only cared about wiping out the members that could effect Nate Johns candidacy, so he would not send John off to track down some low level gang member who might have fled to the other side of the country. It is implied that Jack's father, John, isn't too involved in the boy's life. Home; Service. in his new life as a Blackwater band accountant, that would give him away, like what happened to Michael in GTAV. Ive completed the main story and epilogue for RDR2 months ago, and have been playing the Endless Summer nightly ever since (when Im not online). So, if its going to reference anyone, then it should be him. But John was always very vague about his past throughout Red Dead Redemption. Some of them probably hanged. But, I don't see how it could have been. Unfortunately, Arthur is the only main character in the Red Dead saga who is never mentioned. Also, Morgan probably gets out, wants to make a new name for himself, tells Marston where he's headed, but to keep it a secret, and Marston says he'll never bring his name up again, Arthur Morgan is dead to the world now, and a new man is going to find a life elsewhere. "There's no news coverage. Or something like that. If RDR 1 did have any references to RDR 2, realistically speaking, Arthur wouldnt actually be a likely choice. he figured if the government didint mention them then he wasent going to bring them up. Cutter De Blanc, they all died. Maybe this motivated Rockstar to make a big gang. Morgan isn't low level, pretty sure he's even Dutch's right hand man. Great summary, no need to preorder this game now. Jack and Abigail sit in the living room. Or is it just that rockstar didnt think of arthur at the time of making rdr1? and our Howler 4 years ago #8. It could just be that Morgan did right by Marston at the end, and he had no beef with Morgan. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. abig84 4 years ago #7. Alienous. Right before Morgan's death at the end, choking and sputtering in Marston's arms, he'll say to John with his final words: "Promise me, John don't mention me, don't think about me, don't even acknowledge my previous existence at any point in time. TL;DR - John doesn't mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) He's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back. Red Dead Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. H. See you guys in the next one! gosh who also wants a RDR1 remaster now??lol. I already feel satisfied. That something is redemption for all of his gang members, and Arthur is his most important. He didn't get mentioned the same way Saddie wasn't mentioned, or the native american dude, or Micah Bell, Pearson, Lenny, Joshua, Karen, etc My point is: There's no particular reason for him not being mentioned. RDR2, on the other hand, is littered with ghosts, ghost trains, aliens, giants and other weird things right alongside the main story. Unlike the morally-neutral but honorable family man we see in RDR1, John is much colder. Maybe, uncle was hiding there on the ranch. Because John never mentions him, Arthur Morgan and his story are eventually lost to history. Of course, the IRL reason is that Arthur wasn't created until RDR2. He bit his leash and popped the tire of Francine's bike with his teeth. Just when I think Ive seen them all, I see a new one. They had to return to America broke, taking odd jobs in Strawberry and then Pronghorn Ranch. probably not in a hurry to think about any other former gang members. All rights reserved. But if they could've had the foresight, yeah- it might've been better to mention him just a little. On RDR1 that should have been part 2 because Author was raised by Dutch but he really didn't believe him anymore and Micah either. nicktestbranch, Rockstar tying up loose ends SHAREfactoryhttps://store.playstation.com/#!/en-us/tid=CUSA00572_00 A good ole fashion gunfight in the street, where the game uses a specific system to quick draw on an enemy, whom starts a gunfight in the street or at cards with you. Because Arthur, as Sean puts it, is a skeptic. May 9, 2018 in Red Dead Redemption 2. Even in 1907, he's barely mentioned at all, so history forgot about him. The gang is composed by dozens and dozens of people so why would he be mentioned in particular? This all occurred to me as I was trying to convince my RDR2 has a happy ending.